Three stores sell Indianapolis Colts big & tall apparel online — Fanatics, FansEdge and NFL Shop — and the horseshoe carries one of the biggest catalogs in the league: sixty-plus years of the same logo, from Unitas to Manning to today. This page compares all three for Colts clothing in men’s sizes S through 6X (6XL), tall sizes XLT through 5XLT, and women’s plus sizes 1X, 2X, 3X and 4X — and Fanatics takes this one on every axis that matters to a big & tall shopper.
Please note, we include affiliate links within this post to support the maintenance and development of this site. This is at absolutely no cost to our visitors and helps to support our small business. Thank you for your support.
The Verdict: Colts Big & Tall at Fanatics, NFL Shop and FansEdge
Checked October 31, 2026. A hundred-plus products separate first from second, and the tall list settles it:
- Fanatics 🏆
Men’s Colts range: 1,594 products, plus 940 women’s — the biggest catalog of the three
Tall sizes (XLT–5XLT): Listed in the filter (LT, 2XT, 3XT, 4XT, 5XT) — the fullest tall run of the three
Best for: First stop — biggest range, deepest women’s section, and a dedicated Colts big & tall department (82 products when checked) - NFL Shop
Men’s Colts range: 1,493 products, and 829 women’s
Tall sizes (XLT–5XLT): Listed in the filter (LT, 2XT, 3XT, 4XT)
Best for: Its own big & tall department (also 82 products when checked) and league-exclusive Colts styles - FansEdge
Men’s Colts range: 1,472 products, and 812 women’s
Tall sizes (XLT–5XLT): Listed in the filter (LT, 2XT, 3XT, 4XT)
Best for: A third price on everything, and FansEdge-only designs
Why checking more than one store saves real money
Each shop runs its own promotions on its own days. The hoodie that is full price at one store on Tuesday can be the sale item at another on Wednesday, and the big sizes are usually the first thing a sale clears out.
So the routine that pays: find your team page below, open it at two or three stores, pay the lower price. Bookmark this page — the stores are lined up here side by side, which makes the comparison a thirty-second job instead of six open tabs and a headache.

Colts Sizes, Translated
Stores write the same sizes different ways. Here is the whole run, spelled out:
Regular
- S, M, L, XL — written the same everywhere
- XXL = 2X = 2XL = 2XB
- 3XL = 3X = 3XB
- 4XL = 4X = 4XB
- 5XL = 5X = 5XB
- 6XL = 6X = 6XB
Tall
- XLT = XT = LT
- 2XLT = 2XT
- 3XLT = 3XT
- 4XLT = 4XT
- 5XLT = 5XT
A tall size is not a bigger size — it is the same width with length added through the body and sleeves. If shirts that fit your chest still stop above your belt, you do not need a wider shirt, you need a tall one. On each store’s team page, the sizes are listed in that store’s own spelling; now you can read all three dialects.
3XLT at Lucas Oil: Sizing for an Indoor Team
Colts fans have the best layering problem in football: Lucas Oil Stadium is indoors, so December games are T-shirt weather by kickoff — but the walk in from the lot is Indiana winter. The tall sizes earn their keep exactly there. A 3XLT hoodie is a 3XL’s width with an extra couple of inches of body, which is the difference between a hem that covers your belt while you are standing in the concourse and one that rides up every time you raise your arms for a first down.
Remember the split when you order: chest tight means go up a number (3XL to 4XL); hem short means add the T (3XL to 3XLT). And because Fanatics spelled it LT while the others mixed LT and XT labels when we checked, run your eyes down the translation list above before you pay — the stores are describing the same shirts.
Shop Colts by Size
Here is the size picture for Colts gear — then the department links that get you shopping in your size:
Size Availability: S-XL, XXL, 3XL (3X), 4XL (4X), 5XL (5X), 6XL (6X)
Tall: XLT, 2XLT, 3XLT, 4XLT, 5XLT
Women’s Plus: 1X, 2X, 3X, 4X
- Shop Colts Gear in the Size You Need at Fanatics
- Women’s Indianapolis Colts — All Sizes at Fanatics
- Shop Colts Gear in the Size You Need at FansEdge
- Women’s Indianapolis Colts — All Sizes at FansEdge
- Shop Colts Gear in the Size You Need at NFL Shop
- Women’s Indianapolis Colts — All Sizes at NFL Shop
- Colts Big & Tall Department at NFL Shop
Each department page opens with that store’s size filter down the side — pick your size there and everything shown is actually stocked in it. The big & tall departments skip the filtering step entirely: everything in them starts where regular sizes stop.
For the Shoe: Unitas, Manning, and the Rain in Miami
The horseshoe has been on the helmet since 1953, and Colts fans — “For the Shoe” is the rallying cry — have watched it mean excellence in two cities. Johnny Unitas made the crew cut and the two-minute drill famous in Baltimore; a generation later Peyton Manning turned Indianapolis into a quarterback town, and the run peaked on a rainy night in Miami in February 2007, when the Colts beat the Bears for Super Bowl XLI.
That history is why the throwback rack matters here: Manning and Unitas jerseys are permanent fixtures of the Colts catalogs above, in the big sizes too. Lucas Oil’s giant north window frames downtown Indy behind the end zone — and half the people in the frame are wearing a horseshoe that predates the stadium by five decades.
Questions Colts Shoppers Ask
Do Colts jerseys come in tall sizes?
Yes — Fanatics listed the full tall run for Indianapolis when we checked (LT through 5XT), and NFL Shop and FansEdge list tall as well. Jerseys in tall come and go with restocks; tees, hoodies and jackets hold the tall sizes season-round. Start in the big & tall departments and filter by your size.
Where do I find a Manning throwback in a big size?
In the legends and throwback sections of any of the three stores above — Manning is one of the best-stocked throwback names in the Colts catalog, and the extended sizes are concentrated in the two big & tall departments. Unitas throwbacks run the same route for the longer-memory fans.
Which store is best for women’s plus Colts gear?
Fanatics, on the numbers: 940 women’s products when checked, the deepest of the three, with the plus run to 4X. NFL Shop is the closest alternative at 829 — compare their prices on the same styles before you pay, since their sale days rarely line up.
Keep Digging Around Indianapolis Sports
Indiana’s college team is covered on the Indiana Hoosiers Big & Tall page, and the league’s military-appreciation line on the Salute to Service hoodies page.

